Are Kindle and Nook tablets destined for agencies?

The "FCW Insider" blog recently pondered whether Amazon’s new Kindle Fire would reignite the push for using consumer technology in the office. Now that Barnes and Noble has released the Nook Tablet, the question seems even more relevant.

Neither product is a full-featured tablet computer. They’re essentially high-powered e-readers, but they are sophisticated enough to be useful in offices. They can run apps, stream video smoothly and hold user-generated documents.

Our readers were skeptical, at least judging by their comments. “What difference does it make what device someone wants to play with at the office?" GimmeABreak wrote. "The answer to [the question of connecting] to the network was/is always no. Why would you ever think differently? Keep your toys at home.”

However, that's not entirely correct. At the Veterans Affairs Department, for example, the answer is a cautious, limited yes. As Federal Computer Week reported in late September, VA is allowing about 1,000 employees to use iPads on the agency's network in a test program.

And reader Tim wrote, “Only in government would we be having this conversation. Go to any commercial company, get a job, and tell them you want to be able to connect your personal computer hardware to the company network and see where that gets you.”

Many companies do in fact allow employees to connect personal devices to their networks, as long as the devices meet security standards. “As people pack increasingly sophisticated smart phones in their personal life, they're clamoring to use those gadgets in the workplace as well," the Wall Street Journal reported in April. "And many of their bosses are loosening up. They're ditching the traditional BlackBerry-or-nothing policy and allowing a wider range of mobile devices, including tablets such as the iPad.”

About the Author

Technology journalist Michael Hardy is a former FCW editor.

2014 Rising Star Awards

Help us find the next generation of leaders in federal IT.

Reader comments

Tue, Dec 20, 2011

Learn about your enemy. If the VA leak would have happened with an i-Pad, the owner could have sent a signal and immediately erased the contents. Things change, as does equipment. Humans ability to adapt has made our species successful. I suggest we all get used to doing so more frequently.

Mon, Dec 12, 2011 GimmeABreak Virginia

Quote: "At the Veterans Affairs Department, for example, the answer is a cautious, limited yes." Why should they care about our personal information (PII) being lost. Afterall, the VA Dept isn't known to keep many issues safe, why should they start know? Hmmm ... Didn't they just get have a data leak issue in May 2011? I guess PII rules don't apply to them.

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above