Food for thought: CIOs as venture capitalists
- By Colby Hochmuth
- Jun 27, 2014
At the 2013 ACT-IAC Executive Leadership Conference, federal CIO Steven VanRoekel told the room full of agency CIOs and other IT leaders that he wanted them to be bolder and more strategic.
"I want the CIO at FAA to wake up and go to bed thinking about flight safety and not wondering about email or where am I with commodity contracts," VanRoekel said.
In the seven months since, the federal IT community has said goodbye to many CIOs and other leaders in the space, and lawmakers can't seem to come to an agreement on legislation that would enhance CIO authority. It might be time for a new approach.
A new report from Deloitte, "Technology Trends 2014: Inspiring Disruption," argues that, given the landscape CIOs face today, they need a new mindset for how they manage portfolios and do business.
"More and more CIOs, faced with disruptive forces such as crowdsourcing, mobile only, big data, and cybersecurity, are shifting from a world of known problems into one filled with unknowns," the report says. "To make matters worse, organizational governance has become more complex as barriers for other parts of the business to enter the technical arena have fallen."
Enter the venture capitalist, a business leader that the report suggests CIOs should emulate.
The biggest difference between federal CIOs and venture capitalists is the way they approach and manage risk, Deloitte Global Chief Technology Officer Mark White said. Venture capitalists, of course, invest money across a relatively broad portfolio, making multiple bets. A few will succeed dramatically, some will succeed moderately, and others fail miserably.
CIOs are not nearly as risk-hungry. They don’t want a broad portfolio with a lot of variability, White said, but rather seek the most streamlined portfolio possible.
"Venture capitalists speak in the language of business, and not in the business of technology," White said. "CIOs speak technology."
Part of the reason for the different decision-making processes is motive: venture capitalists are motivated by profit, while CIOs, especially in government, are not. But according to White, that does not mean federal CIOs can’t act like it and adopt some best practices.
The report uses Cisco CIOs as an example. That firm's line-of-business CIOs are encouraged to drive more of their investment portfolio toward change and growth.
The "better, faster, cheaper" mindset is not just applied to the business of IT-- it's just as important to the business of the business, the Deloitte analysts said.
The authors acknowledged, however, that the challenges and barriers presented by government are far different than in the private sector.
The sheer scale of government projects, combined with long budget cycles, strict compliance and policy mandates, and a slow acquisition process make it difficult for agency CIOs to respond and adapt quickly to IT changes.
"Having a VC mind-set means deciding which projects to fund, as well as which are not in the budget or simply lack an appropriate ROI," the report said. "Today, many public sector CIOs lack that authority and budgetary control, but a few pioneers are leading the way. Funding innovation with acceptable risk is never easy and, ironically, never without risk."