What is your e-mail address?

My e-mail address is:

Do you have a password?

Forgot your password? Click here
close

    GAO urges improvements to FISMA

    An auditor recommends steps to improve information security at agencies

    Clarifying agencies' information security obligations, requiring agency executives to ensure that their information security programs are effective, and bolstering oversight from the Office of Management and Budget could improve Federal Information Security Management Act programs, according to government auditors.

    The recommendations from the Government Accountability Office on how to strengthen FISMA come as senators consider legislation to reform the law. Sen. Thomas Carper (D-Del.) introduced legislation in April designed to improve FISMA, which critics say relies too much on paper compliance reports and doesn’t fully fix security vulnerabilities.

    Meanwhile, Gregory Wilshusen, director of information security issues at GAO, told the House Oversight and Government Reform Government Committee's Management, Organization and Procurement Subcommittee in May that many agencies have not fully or effectively implemented key elements of agencywide information security programs, as required by FISMA.

    Wilshusen said GAO’s audits and reviews by agencies' inspectors general found significant deficiencies in information security controls that put agency operations and assets at risk. As a follow-up to that May testimony, the subcommittee’s leaders asked Wilshusen for recommendations to improve FISMA.

    In a letter to the leaders dated June 30, Wilshusen said GAO recommended:

    • Clarifying requirements for how agencies test and evaluate security controls.
    • Requiring that agency executives include in their annual reports to Congress a statement testifying to the overall adequacy and effectiveness of their information security.
    • Bolstering independent annual evaluations by requiring them to be performed in accordance with accepted government auditing standards.
    • Expanding the data that OMB includes in its annual reports on agency compliance.
    • Improving OMB's oversight of agency information security programs to increase accountability.

    About the Author

    Ben Bain is a reporter for Federal Computer Week.

    Reader comments

    Thu, Jul 2, 2009 Fat Cat IRS

    Sorry, this sounds like just more paperwork.

    FISMA has no teeth.

    The solution is not to provide more data to Congress/OMB/GAO etc. but to literaly shut non-compliant systems down after a reasonable time to comply -- In my opinion 18 months. We report weaknesses year after year with Plans of Actions and Milestones (POA&M). When milestones are missed, the systems continue in operation anyway.

    Congress issues its annual 'report card' in which most agencies have poor grades. The systems stay online anyway.

    OMB, through the E300 process threatens to remove funding from non-compliant systems, but those systems remain in operation. Are they running on air? or on money? from where?

    REAL solutions come from real consequences. The current FISMA processes and paperwork are more than enough to identify and quantify systems' weaknesses. We know what they are, but we write explanations instead of doing actual work.

    Thu, Jul 2, 2009

    The title of this article should read "GAO urges improvements to Agencies use of FISMA". No statutory changes to FISMA are required, simply agencies actually following the risk management process contained therein. Even the much praised CAG Guidelines can be incorporated today into the organizational security plan of any agency that wishes to use them. The agencies that actually follow the FISMA risk management approach are seeing real results, while the ones who treat it as a paperwork exercise are crying that "it's just a paperwork exercise"...

    Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

    Your Name:(optional)
    Your Email:(optional)
    Your Location:(optional)
    Comment:
    Please type the letters/numbers you see above

    eSeminar

    • Technology success through the stimulus Karen Jackson

      FCW will present Karen Jackson, deputy secretary of technology for the Commonwealth of Virginia, at 11 a.m. Wed, Dec. 9, in an eSeminar where she will discuss technology acquisition through the stimulus. Read more

    Federal Computer Week eNewsletters

    • Subscribe to Newsletters Subscribe

      Federal Computer Week's eNewsletters deliver the latest policy and management news to your inbox.

    Current issue of FCW