the lectern banner

By Steve Kelman

Blog archive

A burst of Taiwanese democracy at Harvard

A few days ago, I got some emails informing me of two independent events the same afternoon at Harvard, one at the Kennedy School and the other at Harvard's Asia Center. The first event featured the campaign manager for incumbent Taiwan president Ma Ying-jeou and the other the presidential candidate of the opposition Democratic Progressive Party, Tsai Ying-wen.

Both candidates are in the U.S. in the run-up to Taiwan's presidential election next January. Because of my interest in Taiwan, I decided to check out both appearances, expecting two seminar-style events where the candidates would speak to a handful of Taiwan aficionados.

I couldn't have been more wrong.

I arrived at the Kennedy School event a few minutes late to discover an overflow crowd of perhaps 200. The room was so packed, there was virtually no standing room left. Almost everyone there – more than 90 percent, I estimate – were ethnically Chinese or Chinese-American. (It was hard to tell how many were Taiwanese.) Several Taiwanese TV cameras were in the back of the room.

The event began with the vice speaker of the Taiwan legislature giving some introductory remarks in Chinese (translated into English). Then the campaign manager took the dais and noted that his contacts with the U.S. government made it clear that the U.S. approved the less-confrontational stance towards China that the current government, elected in 2008 after two terms of the pro-independence Democratic Progressive Party, had adopted.

He also argued that the softer line on China had allowed an upgrading of Taiwan's perilous non-status status in the world, with observers admitted to the World Health Organization and a doubling of the number of countries – to well over 100 – that give visa waivers to Taiwanese nationals traveling on Taiwanese passports.

He was fairly explicit that President Ma would not give up Taiwanese "sovereignty," a real hot-button issue for China. There were lots of questions from the audience, including some from mainland professors and students studying or researching at Harvard. There was an impassioned question criticizing the government from a Taiwanese professor at the Harvard School of Public Health.

A half-hour later I trudged over to the other side of campus for the second speech. A large crowd was milling outside. It turned out that all the seats were gone, and hundreds of people were being turned away.

Again, these were overwhelmingly Chinese faces. With help from a Kennedy School administrator, I was able to get a seat inside.

The lecture hall was equally crowded at this event, a speech by opposition presidential candidate Tsai Ying-wen. But the tone was boisterous. Before the speech started, Tsai went outside to greet those for whom there was no space. When she was introduced, there was lengthy and thunderous applause from the audience, and lots of cameras flashing.

(There has been applause at the government party talk too, but it was restrained).

A key theme of her speech was that democracy was a central feature defining Taiwanese culture -- the Taiwanese peacefully transitioned from dictatorship to democracy over the past 10 to 20 years -- linking Taiwan to the United States and distinguishing it from China. She appealed to China to transition to democracy, so that China's rise in the world could be welcomed rather than feared, and so that China would, as she put it, associate itself with the universal values of the international community.

(Tsai was non-committal on the question of whether Chinese democracy would ease Taiwanese reunification with the Mainland, which a student raised. Tsai said only that it would make Taiwanese people feel more friendly to China.) A number of Taiwanese-American Harvard undergraduates asked Tsai for her views on how they should relate to Taiwan and to China. Many of Tsai's answers to questions were interrupted by applause.

As I understand it, one of the two speakers (I'm not sure which one) decided to come to Harvard when the other announced they would.

Originally, they scheduled themselves for the same time, but somehow an agreement was reached to separate the speeches by 45 minutes and half a mile. Harvard's status in Asia assured there would be Taiwanese TV cameras there.

The afternoon was unexpected and exhilarating. Hundreds of people came out for what were two high-spirited celebrations of democracy. To those in both audiences, I think, democracy in Taiwan was a treasure to be cherished and be grateful for.

 

Posted on Sep 16, 2011 at 12:09 PM


Featured

Reader comments

Mon, Oct 24, 2011

The Epoch Times recently ran an article on mental illness and the high number of suicides in communist China throughout all social classes. The conclusion was that hopelessness prevailed especially among the lower class. Its nice to know the protests groups outside authoritarian countries have an outlet for their frustrations but they need to review carefully their solutions. Giving more power to goverment only results in darkness. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.

Sat, Sep 24, 2011 Dung Fang Hung

Sailing the seas depends upon the Helmsman. ROC may be a self proclaimed democracy, but it has the feel of a police state when it comes to politics. My favorite political ritual in Taipei is watching members of Parliament punch each other and break chairs over each others' heads. No denying that a country that embraces that form of colloquy must have a lot of freedom. It will take the passing of one or two more ROC generations, but there is no question that ROC will come back into the fold of Mother China, and peacefully. The pull of culture and money will overcome political differences, eh? And, professor, as long as you obviously love the role played for Taiwan officials, you should do more to mesh PRC and Taiwan students and visiting scholars and politicians. Thanks for your efforts.

Sat, Sep 17, 2011 Steve Kelman

Here is a YouTube video that shows Tsai Ing-wen gretting the students who couldn't get into her lecture. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ntfEkqDBLA

Fri, Sep 16, 2011 Ian Ouyang Xi'an,China

Taiwanese Democracy is something that we, part of the netizens, are quite envious of.We often compare the offsprings of nation founder Mao zedong with those of Jiang jieshi; and it's always a tearful joke on the Internet. When some Chinese from the mainlands cross the Straits, watching political debating in the hotel sometimes become one of the desirable things to do. Compared with Taiwanese Democracy, recently some electing events happened in the mainland are mortifying.
Those independent candidates tried to join the congress campaign, but ended up failure with unbelievably unfairness, which has frustrated me a little bit.

Fri, Sep 16, 2011 Horace Cambridge

I had breakfast with the KMT delegation this morning and it was an interesting discussion that covered a variety of different topics. Stepping back it really looks like a contest between quantitative and an emotional contestants. The KMT focuses on the numbers - low unemployment (4.3%), economic growth (10+%), stability, trade, international relations etc. The DPP is pushing image, democracy and a grass roots organization. It'll be fascinating to see how the two sides marshal their resources and electorate to try and win this pivotal election.

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above