Congress legislates, procrastinates on tech
- By Natasha Haubold
- Apr 17, 2000
Not all members of Congress are as technologically savvy as the people
Every year members of Congress debate information technology bills on
topics ranging from bridging the digital divide to e-government to online
procurement. But as Congress pushes technology mandates on federal agencies,
Congress itself is slow to enter the Information Age, according to industry
experts who gathered last month at a conference to discuss the Hill's technology
A Senate staff member who asked not to be identified said she had to explain
to her boss how to access the Internet and use a mouse so that the senator
could view his own World Wide Web site.
"Not all [members of Congress] are familiar with the latest technology,"
the staff member said. "We not only have to bridge the digital divide in
the nation but in Congress as well."
While technology offers great opportunities to immediately respond to
constituents' requests, many members of Congress are leery of using technology
to correspond, according to Vic Fazio, senior partner at Clark and Weinstock
and a former Democratic congressman from California.
"It is difficult to tell who has sent an e-mail message and where it
came from," Fazio said during a March 29 Library of Congress Conference.
"Most members are not interested in the views of those who don't vote for
them or have the potential to vote for them, so when an office is inundated
with messages it is sometimes easier not to respond."
According to Daniel Mulhollan, director of Congressional Research Services
at the Library of Congress, many congressional staffs are fearful of using
technology because electronic records created are not always confidential.
"I have been told by several staffs that they have a policy not to create
anything electronically that they wouldn't want to see printed on the front
page in the morning," he said. "There is always a chance that e-mail messages
or information on your hard drive may be subpoenaed."
Legislators fear that their successors could access — and in some cases
have accessed — confidential electronic documents left behind to "create
hay," Fazio added. "You may think a document was deleted from your computer
and it hasn't been. It has made people afraid to put anything in writing
and has impeded the conversation flow."
But the fear of misuse should not supersede a member's use of technology,
said Mary Jane Collipriest, public affairs officer for Sen. Robert Bennett
(R-Utah). "There is risk in any information sharing. You have to weigh the
benefits of using technology, which greatly outweighs the cons."
Bennett's office uses technology whenever possible. Technology has helped
staff members stay in touch with one another as well as with constituents
and fellow members of Congress.
"The technology is here to stay. It has permeated our lives and is an
undeniable fact of life," Collipriest said. "By not using technology we
are robbing ourselves of a valuable tool."
Congress members' fears about using new technology have not been confined
to individual legislative offices. In 1995 Congress approved the distribution
of laptop computers to all incoming freshmen. Laptops provided access to
the congressional intranet so that newcomers could keep up on legislation
and learn about Congress prior to taking office.
What Congress forgot to tell the newly elected senators and representatives,
however, was that electronic devices were not allowed on the floor of neither
the House nor the Senate.
However, nearly one-third of all state legislatures allow personal electronic
devices in their chambers, according to a congressional report released
in July 1999. In California, General Assembly members use laptops "to instantly
access analyses of the bills prepared each session by nonpartisan scholars,
bill digests and status, the complete history of each bill, and the members'
previous votes on bills," the report stated.
Sen. Mike Enzi (R-Wyo.) believes that laptops would be an asset to the
congressional process and plans to introduce legislation this year which
will allow laptops on the floor, said Lindsay Holmen, deputy press secretary
"Laptops would allow for volumes of information to be available at a
[member's] fingertips," she said. "It would save [members of Congress] from
ruffling through piles of papers which is very distracting. [Enzi] wants
to make sure the legislative branch is not weakened because it is relying
on old technology."