Report seeks classification guidance

“Unintended Audience: Balancing Openness and Secrecy”

A couple of years ago when federal government officials got wind of Sean Gorman's dissertation -- which provided a detailed map of the nation's fiber-optic network -- they wanted to classify it.

Although Gorman, then a George Mason University student, used public records to compile his map, government officials contended if the information fell into terrorist hands it could potentially be used to attack the country. University officials said they would ensure that the data is secure and protected. Even former cybersecurity czar Richard Clarke was quoted as saying the student should turn the paper in, get a grade and then burn it.

But the example underscores a larger problem about unclassified but sensitive data found in the public, academic, and private arenas that could pose a security risk. There has been a mixed practice of dealing with such types of data, said Jacques Gansler, a public policy professor at the University of Maryland.

Gansler and his colleague William Lucyshyn, a visiting senior research scholar and a current research director at the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, recently released a 76-page report that calls for new federal guidelines that balance the need for greater security with society's need for openness.

"Right now, there's a lot of ambiguity," said Gansler, a former undersecretary of defense for acquisition, technology and logistics from 1997 to 2001.

He said he does not know of any integrated federal approach to create a comprehensive and consistent policy for the classification of such information. When situations such as Gorman's dissertation come to light, the federal government usually errs on the side of classifying information. That is not necessarily always a good thing.

"In general, what I'm afraid of is that it's right now heading in the direction of overly restricting information rather than openness," he said. "In other words, if you let the security people to make the decisions you go pretty hard over in one direction. And the United States can suffer significantly by closing down some of what has been restrained [and hamper] our ability to research and to share data, for example."

The report outlines a framework that Gansler described as a limited beginning. It calls for the president, in consultation with the Homeland Security and Justice departments, to issue an executive order that identifies the types of information -- relating to weapons of mass destruction, critical infrastructure, intelligence and security -- as Controlled Unclassified Security Information (CUSI).

The CUSI classification would enable individuals and organizations across the public, private and academic sectors apply a consistent policy on what they could share but also allow the federal government or others to identify analyze interdependencies and potentially mitigate vulnerabilities.

Gansler and Lucyshyn also call for an effort to educate personnel about the concepts, rules and guidelines of CUSI as well as provide an appeals process to allow a review on a case-by-case basis.

The private and academic sectors are concerned about the Gorman incident, Gansler said. Many observers fear that students, professors or employees from foreign countries may be denied access to sensitive material needed for research and development.

For example, a large percentage of a software or medical research company may have a professional staff that is foreign. The companies are concerned they may not have access to certain types of research or might not be able to publish sensitive research. That doesn't mean all research should be available because somebody might come up with a new pathogen that you don't want published, he said.

"There are valid concerns in this area but it should be very limited," he said. "And the fear is it won't be limited. They'll err on the side of making sure that anything that possibly could be used by a terrorist will therefore be instantly classified."

Another problem is determining penalties. For example, if the George Mason University student decided to publish his dissertation with sensitive information, Gansler said the student might never get a security clearance to work in the federal government. And officials need to figure out what to do with sensitive-but-nonclassified material.

"What if this guy from GMU has been told he can't publish it but he's not been told what do I do with all the material gathered? Do I put it under lock and key? Do I have to have a security guard outside and so forth? It's largely a matter of codification, of what fits under that category -- preferably very limited -- and how to control it what penalties might exist," Gansler said.

He said the issue is not an easy one to grapple with, but that the federal government has to address it in a more systematic approach.

The Fed 100

Read the profiles of all this year's winners.


  • Then-presidential candidate Donald Trump at a 2016 campaign event. Image: Shutterstock

    'Buy American' order puts procurement in the spotlight

    Some IT contractors are worried that the "buy American" executive order from President Trump could squeeze key innovators out of the market.

  • OMB chief Mick Mulvaney, shown here in as a member of Congress in 2013. (Photo credit Gage Skidmore/Flickr)

    White House taps old policies for new government makeover

    New guidance from OMB advises agencies to use shared services, GWACs and federal schedules for acquisition, and to leverage IT wherever possible in restructuring plans.

  • Shutterstock image (by Everett Historical): aerial of the Pentagon.

    What DOD's next CIO will have to deal with

    It could be months before the Defense Department has a new CIO, and he or she will face a host of organizational and operational challenges from Day One

  • USAF Gen. John Hyten

    General: Cyber Command needs new platform before NSA split

    U.S. Cyber Command should be elevated to a full combatant command as soon as possible, the head of Strategic Command told Congress, but it cannot be separated from the NSA until it has its own cyber platform.

  • Image from Shutterstock.

    DLA goes virtual

    The Defense Logistics Agency is in the midst of an ambitious campaign to eliminate its IT infrastructure and transition to using exclusively shared, hosted and virtual services.

  • Fed 100 logo

    The 2017 Federal 100

    The women and men who make up this year's Fed 100 are proof positive of what one person can make possibile in federal IT. Read on to learn more about each and every winner's accomplishments.

Reader comments

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above

More from 1105 Public Sector Media Group