Review board to Obama: Shut down NSA program

surveillance camera

A bipartisan board charged with analyzing the National Security Agency's bulk data-collection practices voted 3-2 to recommend ending the mass perusal of phone records of U.S. citizens, a more sweeping step than reform efforts outlined by President Barack Obama last week.

The Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board, in a much-anticipated report released Jan. 23, recommended shuttering the so-called "215 program," named for the section of the 2001 anti-terrorism law known as the Patriot Act, which authorized the government to scoop up communications data. Two dissenters on the board who voted against halting the 215 program defended the surveillance activities as critical to national security.

In a public meeting in Washington on Jan. 23, the five board members outlined their decision, which goes a step beyond the presidential directive issued Jan. 17 addressing the same subject. The directive called for a series of tweaks to the program, without shutting down the collection of phone records. The PCLOB decision recommends ending U.S. telephone surveillance.

"The bottom line of our report: The majority of the PCLOB believes that the 215 program is inconsistent with the statute that authorizes it on a number of grounds," said Chairman David Medine. He noted that the program provides no connection to a specific FBI investigation at the time of collection, and since it potentially encompasses all telephone records across the nation, it cannot be regarded as relevant to a particular investigation. He also noted that the statute authorizes only the FBI to collect from telephone providers, yet it is the NSA that receives the information.

"The majority of the board takes the view that the 215 program is not authorized by statute, it raises serious constitutional and privacy concerns, and it has not demonstrated sufficient effectiveness to continue in operation on a permanent basis," Medine said.

The board's findings were not unanimous, with two members, Rachel Brand and Elisebeth Collins Cook, endorsing the program.

"In today's world of never-ending and varied threats, I believe a tool such as section 215 that allows investigators to triage and focus on those who are more likely to be doing harm to or in the United States, or allows investigators to dismiss potential homeland connections to ongoing terror plots, is valuable," Cook said. "This allows us to connect the dots and paint a fuller picture of our adversaries."

Brand added that it is too soon to adequately gauge the success of the program – and highlighted the difficulty in doing so.

"There is no easy way to calculate the value of this program; there is no clear test," Brand said. "But the test cannot be whether it has already been a key factor in thwarting a previously unknown terrorist attack. Assessing the benefit of a preventive program like this one requires a longer-term view."

Brand also suggested that the program is not a threat to privacy because the records do not contain personally identifiable information, but rather series of numbers – an argument other supporters of the surveillance activities have made, including officials within the intelligence community.

Privacy advocates reject that premise.

"There may be no names literally within the database, but it's incredibly easy to correlate a phone number with a name," said Rachel Levinson-Waldman, counsel to the liberty and national security program at New York University's Brennan Center. "Content has been one of the biggest red herrings, the idea of 'no content itself' in the databases. But it's interesting how much we've all learned over the past year about metadata and how revealing it is – sometimes more so than content."

About the Author

Amber Corrin is a former staff writer for FCW and Defense Systems.

The Fed 100

Save the date for 28th annual Federal 100 Awards Gala.


  • computer network

    How Einstein changes the way government does business

    The Department of Commerce is revising its confidentiality agreement for statistical data survey respondents to reflect the fact that the Department of Homeland Security could see some of that data if it is captured by the Einstein system.

  • Defense Secretary Jim Mattis. Army photo by Monica King. Jan. 26, 2017.

    Mattis mulls consolidation in IT, cyber

    In a Feb. 17 memo, Defense Secretary Jim Mattis told senior leadership to establish teams to look for duplication across the armed services in business operations, including in IT and cybersecurity.

  • Image from

    DHS vague on rules for election aid, say states

    State election officials had more questions than answers after a Department of Homeland Security presentation on the designation of election systems as critical U.S. infrastructure.

  • Org Chart Stock Art - Shutterstock

    How the hiring freeze targets millennials

    The government desperately needs younger talent to replace an aging workforce, and experts say that a freeze on hiring doesn't help.

  • Shutterstock image: healthcare digital interface.

    VA moves ahead with homegrown scheduling IT

    The Department of Veterans Affairs will test an internally developed scheduling module at primary care sites nationwide to see if it's ready to service the entire agency.

  • Shutterstock images (honglouwawa & 0beron): Bitcoin image overlay replaced with a dollar sign on a hardware circuit.

    MGT Act poised for a comeback

    After missing in the last Congress, drafters of a bill to encourage cloud adoption are looking for a new plan.

Reader comments

Fri, Jan 24, 2014

Well isn't this special? Bush implemented this after the 9/11 attacks and Obama essentially endorsed and continued it (as evidensed by not getting rid of it for 6 years, then not hobbling it when his base wants him to). If two presidents believe it is in the national interest to continue it, we should probably keep it.

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above

More from 1105 Public Sector Media Group