NIH research yields dividends

With the goal of the National Institutes of Health's 15-year project to catalog and map human DNA becoming more of a reality— and potentially commercially profitable— two businesses this summer turned the effort into a race that pits the government against the private sector.

NIH began its ambitious effort to use computers to map human DNA in 1988, when it joined the Energy Department's study of the effects of radiation on survivors of the atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. In 1990, the two agencies launched the $3 billion Human Genome Project, with plans to complete the project in 2005. In May, Celera Genomics Corp., headed up by former NIH researcher Dr. Craig Venter, announced it would complete the sequencing in three years at one-tenth the cost. Just last month, newly formed Incyte Pharmaceuticals Inc. said it would finish the process in 12 to 24 months for about the same money.

The easy— but misguided— conclusion here would be to ask NIH to step aside, save taxpayer money and let the seemingly more cost-efficient private firms complete the coding. After all, didn't Economics 101 teach us that the private sector can accomplish the same goals as government more quickly and cheaply?

The devil, as they say, is in the details. Celera's approach, some argue, will not create as complete a DNA map as NIH's and will yield only short-term benefits. Incyte said it would include only ''commercially relevant information,'' or about 90 percent of all human DNA.

One of the primary functions of government is to conduct basic research that is too costly and not profitable for the private sector to undertake, yet may eventually yield significant societal benefits. Where would these companies be if not for the decade of public investment in the Human Genome Project, a scientific feat possibly greater than the creation of the periodic table of elements?

But government research does have its drawbacks. Venter left NIH in 1992 after he became frustrated by obstacles in funding and patenting a new sequencing technique that made it easier to identify genes. Governmental red tape ultimately can jeopardize a scientific endeavor.

It would be shortsighted to conclude that Congress should cut back on its investment in information technologies to support research in health, the environment or a related area because of a perception that the private sector can simply do it better. NIH's project is important because it is driven by motives other than profits and could yield more useful information later. Despite the highly publicized, private-sector initiatives to map genetic code, the Human Genome project and others like it remain a good investment.

Featured

  • Telecommunications
    Stock photo ID: 658810513 By asharkyu

    GSA extends EIS deadline to 2023

    Agencies are getting up to three more years on existing telecom contracts before having to shift to the $50 billion Enterprise Infrastructure Solutions vehicle.

  • Workforce
    Shutterstock image ID: 569172169 By Zenzen

    OMB looks to retrain feds to fill cyber needs

    The federal government is taking steps to fill high-demand, skills-gap positions in tech by retraining employees already working within agencies without a cyber or IT background.

  • Acquisition
    GSA Headquarters (Photo by Rena Schild/Shutterstock)

    GSA to consolidate multiple award schedules

    The General Services Administration plans to consolidate dozens of its buying schedules across product areas including IT and services to reduce duplication.

Stay Connected

FCW Update

Sign up for our newsletter.

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.