Court halts electronic records case

The legal battle to stop federal agencies from deleting electronic records

is over, and the agencies have won. But the lawyer who led the effort to

save digital documents said he will renew his fight on a different front.

The Supreme Count Monday declined to hear the case of Public Citizen v.

Carlin, sinking the public interest organization's hopes that it might force

agencies to save electronic documents, including e-mail messages, in an

easy-to-search, easy-to-access electronic form.

Michael Tankersley, a lawyer for Public Citizen, said he plans to begin

petitioning agencies and taking other steps to persuade them to preserve

electronic records.

John Carlin, national archivist, said the Supreme Court's decision should

end three years of legal skirmishing regarding the fate of electronic records.

He said the National Archives and Records Administration he heads now can

"continue in an orderly way to develop practical methods for managing and

preserving records in the Electronic Era."

The Supreme Court's decision leaves intact a NARA policy that lets agencies

delete electronic records if paper copies have been made for permanent storage.

The Supreme Court did not say why it declined to hear the case.

In 1997, Public Citizen won a federal court ruling that the original electronic

versions of records must be saved if the records have historic value. The

government appealed the ruling in 1998, and the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals

overturned it. Public Citizen then appealed to the Supreme Court.

Tankersley and others contend that the electronic version of records contain

information that is often not preserved when the records are printed on

paper. Such information may indicate who reviewed a memo or who participated

in a policy decision. Electronic records are also much easier than paper

ones to search, and they can be accessed by researchers online.

Government lawyers argued that many federal agencies did not have the electronic

recordkeeping systems capable of properly saving electronic records.

During the years of litigation, however, electronic record storage capabilities

improved, and NARA policies about preserving electronic records evolved.

Tankersley took some credit for raising awareness of electronic storage



  • IT Modernization
    shutterstock image By enzozo; photo ID: 319763930

    OMB provides key guidance for TMF proposals amid surge in submissions

    Deputy Federal CIO Maria Roat details what makes for a winning Technology Modernization Fund proposal as agencies continue to submit major IT projects for potential funding.

  • gears and money (zaozaa19/

    Worries from a Democrat about the Biden administration and federal procurement

    Steve Kelman is concerned that the push for more spending with small disadvantaged businesses will detract from the goal of getting the best deal for agencies and taxpayers.

Stay Connected