New rules offer mutual fund tax alert
- By Milt x_Zall
- Aug 10, 2001
Many investors have been angered by the large tax bills they've had to pay
on capital gains distributions from mutual funds that lost money in 2000.
New mutual fund rules issued by the Securities and Exchange Commission
won't prevent such large tax bills, but may make investors more aware of
the impact of taxes on their portfolio returns. The SEC's new rules went
into effect April 16, the deadline for filing 2000 tax returns.
Show After-Tax Returns
The new rules call for stock and bond mutual funds (not money market
funds) to include standardized tables in their prospectuses that show the
after-tax returns of the funds for the past year, five years and 10 years.
This is in addition to pre-tax returns the funds already must report.
The after-tax reports come in two versions. One, called the pre-liquidation
method, assumes that the shareholder is not selling fund shares. The one-year
after-tax figure reflects all taxable interest, dividends and short-term
capital gains or losses that the fund generates from its sale of securities.
The SEC requires that funds calculate the tax on these distributions
using the highest ordinary income tax rate at the time of distributions,
not at the time of calculation. Currently, that top federal rate is 39.6
percent. Under the five- and 10-year scenarios, the capital gains are assumed
to be long-term and are taxed at the maximum capital gains rate in effect
at the time of distributions, which currently is 20 percent.
Some critics feel that use of the 39.6 percent income tax rate overstates
the impact of taxes on returns for most investors. They say that 28 percent
should be used because more investors fall into that tax bracket. However,
the SEC wanted to use a "worst-case scenario," and regardless of the rate
used, the comparisons have value because all funds must use the same rate.
The second after-tax reporting method, called post-liquidation, assumes
that the shareholder has sold all shares at the end of the three holding
periods, with short-term capital gains (or losses) calculated for the one-year
period, and long-term ones assessed for the five- and 10-year periods.
Be aware that these new rules only apply to taxable mutual funds. They
won't affect funds whose prospectuses are used only for tax-favored accounts
such as 401(k) plans and Individual Retirement Accounts, because those investors
don't pay taxes on the earnings until they withdraw funds.
Your Tax Bite
So, how might you as an investor benefit from these new rules? The major
rationale the SEC gives for this new requirement is that "taxes are one
of the most significant costs of investing in mutual funds," and that these
after-tax return numbers should better inform shareholders how their funds
are doing in this area.
The SEC says more than 2.5 percent of the average stock fund's total
return is lost to taxes, which is more than is lost to fund fees. The SEC
also noted that the impact of these taxes varies tremendously among funds,
from zero to as high as 5.6 percent, according to some studies. The tax
impact depends on several factors, including how often the fund trades;
the amount of gains accumulated (many tech funds selling in 2000 had run
up large accumulations); and whether the fund manager tries to offset gains
Although most investment experts are applauding the SEC's rules (even
as they may disagree with the 39.6 percent tax rate required), some point
out that the rules don't require the funds to spell out their tax policies:
How exactly does the fund handle tax issues, or does it even pay any attention
Dennis Filangeri, a certified financial planner, says that while the
tax bite is certainly important when looking at a fund, you should not make
investment decisions based on taxes alone. For example, more important is
whether the investment objectives of a specific mutual fund fit your individual
needs. Also keep in mind that when you pay annual taxes on share earnings,
and you reinvest those earnings in the same fund, those earnings add to
your cost basis and won't be taxed again when you ultimately sell the fund
Nonetheless, the after-tax reporting rules will help inform investors,
say investment experts, and perhaps in the long run, such disclosure will
compel more funds to be tax sensitive.
Zall, Bureaucratus columnist and a retired federal employee, is a freelance
writer based in Silver Spring, Md. He specializes in taxes, investing, business
and government workplace issues. He is a certified internal auditor and
a registered investment adviser. He can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org.