GAO sees e-rulemaking holes

GAO report: Electronic Rulemaking: Efforts to Facilitate Public Participation Can Be Improved

Related Links

Three agencies that accounted for more than half of all published rule proposals in a three-month period did not identify all the rules for comment, making public participation difficult, General Accounting Office officials said in a report released today.

Conversely, the Web site, one of the e-government initiatives, identified nearly all of these rules for comment but the design sometimes complicated finding the rules, the GAO said.

" allowed the public to provide electronic comments on about 91 percent of the 411 proposed rules that were published during this three-month period," the report states. "In contrast, the rulemaking agencies provided for e-comments in only about 66 percent of the rules."

Between February and April 2003, the Environmental Protection Agency, Transportation Department and Agriculture Department were responsible more than half of the 411 proposed rules published in the federal register. The EPA and DOT identified only about 20 percent of their agencies rules. The USDA did not list any of the rules, but Web sites for agencies within the department did so for most of the rules, GAO said.

For the rules that were published, some agencies, such as the EPA, did not provide any means for public comments, but did, the report said. However, only two of the publications pointed to, which could explain why relatively few comments were submitted through the site, the report said.

To improve the visibility of, GAO officials recommended that agencies mention the site as a commenting option. The Office of Management and Budget should also issue guidance to the rulemaking agencies on ways to improve the commenting process and provide a link to on their Web sites, officials said.

GAO auditors found that was more consistent in allowing for public comment.

"Our study indicated that more directly and more comprehensively allowed the public to identify proposed rules that were open for comment that the three major rulemaking agencies' electronic systems that we examined," the report said.

But the report noted a few problems with that makes accessing the rules easier. Users must search through a dozen or more links to find a complete list of rules open for comment, the GAO said. The site also does not identify rules using the their titles as they appear in the federal register, the report said. didn't provide electronic access to supporting materials, such as an agencies' economic analyses. Officials at the EPA, which is the managing partner for the, said the site was not designed for ancillary documentation, although the second module, which is expected to be ready by the end of 2005, would include that information, according to GAO officials.

In comments to the GAO report, the EPA program manager noted that was intended to be an interim comment system and had only been operating for a short amount of time when it was reviewed, according to the report. USDA officials indicated to the GAO that they agreed with the report and would make changes based on the findings.


  • Congress
    Rep. Jim Langevin (D-R.I.) at the Hack the Capitol conference Sept. 20, 2018

    Jim Langevin's view from the Hill

    As chairman of of the Intelligence and Emerging Threats and Capabilities subcommittee of the House Armed Services Committe and a member of the House Homeland Security Committee, Rhode Island Democrat Jim Langevin is one of the most influential voices on cybersecurity in Congress.

  • Comment
    Pilot Class. The author and Barbie Flowers are first row third and second from right, respectively.

    How VA is disrupting tech delivery

    A former Digital Service specialist at the Department of Veterans Affairs explains efforts to transition government from a legacy "project" approach to a more user-centered "product" method.

  • Cloud
    cloud migration

    DHS cloud push comes with complications

    A pressing data center closure schedule and an ensuing scramble to move applications means that some Homeland Security components might need more than one hop to get to the cloud.

Stay Connected


Sign up for our newsletter.

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.