Judge dismisses NARA suit

A federal judge's decision this week left unclear whether an executive order trumps a congressional statute in matters involving access to presidential records.

Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly, of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, dismissed a lawsuit brought by historians against the National Archives and Records Administration. The historians alleged that NARA had blocked access to 68,000 pages of former President Ronald Reagan's records.

The district judge dismissed the case March 28 as moot because NARA had released the sought-after records before the conclusion of the lawsuit. But as a consequence, Kollar-Kotelly failed to rule on what she wrote was the principle of the case: Did President George W. Bush overstep the limitations of his power when he issued an executive order altering the terms of the Presidential Records Act of 1978?

The American Historical Association, which filed the lawsuit, had asked the court to overrule the executive order that Bush issued on Nov. 1, 2001, as "an impermissible exercise of executive power." Bush's executive order put new restrictions on records to which public access had been guaranteed under the Presidential Records Act.

Under the statute, restrictions to many presidential records expire 12 years after a president leaves office. But Bush's order asserts a constitutionally based privilege to former presidential and vice presidential records that does not expire. Access to those records can be gained only at the discretion of the sitting president in consultation with the former president, if the former president is still living.

Featured

  • Defense
    Ryan D. McCarthy being sworn in as Army Secretary Oct. 10, 2019. (Photo credit: Sgt. Dana Clarke/U.S. Army)

    Army wants to spend nearly $1B on cloud, data by 2025

    Army Secretary Ryan McCarthy said lack of funding or a potential delay in the JEDI cloud bid "strikes to the heart of our concern."

  • Congress
    Rep. Jim Langevin (D-R.I.) at the Hack the Capitol conference Sept. 20, 2018

    Jim Langevin's view from the Hill

    As chairman of of the Intelligence and Emerging Threats and Capabilities subcommittee of the House Armed Services Committe and a member of the House Homeland Security Committee, Rhode Island Democrat Jim Langevin is one of the most influential voices on cybersecurity in Congress.

Stay Connected

FCW INSIDER

Sign up for our newsletter.

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.