Princeton study says federal careerists make better managers

"Political Appointments, Bureau Chiefs and Federal Management Performance"

Related Links

Agency experience and long tenure in government make the best federal managers, according to a recent Princeton University study of federal management performance. The study is timely with public scrutiny now focused on the performance of political appointees at the Federal Emergency Management Agency.

Based on scores from the Bush administration’s Program Assessment Rating Tool (PART), the study found that political appointees have higher education levels and more varied work experiences. But it also found that those résumé facts do not make appointees better managers than career federal employees.

The PART scores, which rate how well managers lead federal programs, are useful for analyzing variations in management performance, even though the scores are imperfect, said the report’s author, David Lewis, an assistant professor of politics and public affairs at Princeton.

For the study, Lewis used PART scores from 614 federal programs.

Lewis wrote that the study confirms the claim of the National Commission on the Public Service, which has suggested that increasing the number of appointees could be bad for federal agency performance.

“The persistent willingness of presidents to keep a large number of appointees, even when this is bad for management, suggests that presidents are willing to trade management competence in order to secure ideological consistency or loyalty and satisfy demands for patronage,” according to a report on the study.

Lewis wrote that future research should explore the question of how the president and federal lawmakers make decisions about whether appointees or careerists should manage federal programs.


  • Comment
    Pilot Class. The author and Barbie Flowers are first row third and second from right, respectively.

    How VA is disrupting tech delivery

    A former Digital Service specialist at the Department of Veterans Affairs explains efforts to transition government from a legacy "project" approach to a more user-centered "product" method.

  • Cloud
    cloud migration

    DHS cloud push comes with complications

    A pressing data center closure schedule and an ensuing scramble to move applications means that some Homeland Security components might need more than one hop to get to the cloud.

  • Comment
    Blue Signage and logo of the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs

    Doing digital differently at VA

    The Department of Veterans Affairs CIO explains why digital transformation is not optional.

Stay Connected


Sign up for our newsletter.

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.