Senate looks for lessons from alternative pay systems

Many agencies have been using alternatives to the General Schedule pay system for more than a decade, which prompted Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) to ask witnesses at a hearing today whether some of those could be expanded governmentwide.

Collins said lawmakers and agency managers should study how well alternative systems are working before changing. The Homeland Security and Defense departments and White House officials have crafted new personnel systems from scratch, which they want to implement. But employee unions are putting up considerable resistance to the changes.

Officials at the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. and the National Institute of Standards and Technology testified that those agencies have replaced the General Schedule with pay increases based almost entirely on employee performance. After leaving the safety net of the General Schedule, FDIC employees initially filed more labor grievances to complain about their pay, said Arleas Upton Kea, director of the FDIC’s Administration Division.

Despite mixed reviews for the new pay system, most employees are adapting and are more productive, Kea said. The FDIC is on its fourth version of a pay-for-performance system that the agency continues to revise in response to employee feedback, she said.

Sen. George Voinovich (R-Ohio), chairman of a subcommittee of the Senate Homeland Security and Government Affairs Committee, said he was concerned whether the Office of Personnel Management could handle governmentwide training of managers that would be required to make performance-based pay systems work fairly. The subcommittee, which oversees the federal workforce, among other concerns, held the hearing.

Dan Blair, deputy director of OPM, said the agency could handle the additional responsibilities, if lawmakers provide adequate funding. “We’re subject to the vagaries of the appropriations process, and that’s not helpful to us,” he said.


  • Comment
    Pilot Class. The author and Barbie Flowers are first row third and second from right, respectively.

    How VA is disrupting tech delivery

    A former Digital Service specialist at the Department of Veterans Affairs explains efforts to transition government from a legacy "project" approach to a more user-centered "product" method.

  • Cloud
    cloud migration

    DHS cloud push comes with complications

    A pressing data center closure schedule and an ensuing scramble to move applications means that some Homeland Security components might need more than one hop to get to the cloud.

  • Comment
    Blue Signage and logo of the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs

    Doing digital differently at VA

    The Department of Veterans Affairs CIO explains why digital transformation is not optional.

Stay Connected


Sign up for our newsletter.

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.