Kelman: The grand challenge

DARPA offered $2 million for the first driverless vehicle to cross the finish line

There was a good procurement news story recently about the second running of the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency's Grand Challenge. The Grand Challenge is a race in which entrants -- 23 of them this year -- develop driverless vehicles designed to navigate a 140-mile course through the desert.

DARPA offered a $2 million prize to the first vehicle to make it to the finish line. Seeking to encourage development of technology that can be used for riderless vehicles in battle, the agency held the first Grand Challenge in March 2004. That time, no vehicle was able to finish. This time, five did. The contest stimulated technological progress.

The Grand Challenge could be seen as an innovative procurement process -- procurement by contest. Indeed, at the time of the first one, I wrote about it in a Federal Computer Week column.

However, there's been a lot of water under the procurement bridge in the past 20 months. Since the first Grand Challenge, the attention of politicians and reporters has been on other things, such as real and alleged procurement scandals.

The nation is lucky that the Grand Challenge developed before the recent political and media focus. Would the Grand Challenge have much chance of getting off the ground today? I don't think so.

For starters, in today's environment, people are being encouraged or intimidated to put their time and energy into keeping their noses clean to avoid doing something wrong, instead of thinking about better ways of doing business so they can do something right.

Beyond that, today the Grand Challenge would be seen as risky. The biggest problem would be that DARPA was offering the winner $2 million without regard to how much the individual or team had spent.

What if the winner had spent only $50,000 plus graduate student volunteer time, thus making a profit of something like 4,000 percent? (I don't believe this was the case, but the government had no way of knowing in advance.)

Contest rules didn't allow government auditors to check the winner's costs. Think of the risks the agency runs of being targeted by a fleecing-of-America story or a press release from a watchdog group.

Furthermore, the government did not prescribe and inspect for use of specific designs or methods. In other words, this was a performance-based procurement, described recently in the Washington Post as a nontraditional approach -- heaven forbid! -- requiring extra vigilance so government isn't bamboozled.

Simply as a new buying method, the Grand Challenge created risks DARPA might not have known about initially, but they could come back to haunt it.

Today the event would be unlikely to be conceived in the first place, and if it were proposed, it almost certainly would not be approved. People would spend their energy on other aspects of procurement. Is this how we want things to be?

Kelman is a professor of public management at Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government and former administrator of the Office of Federal Procurement Policy. He can be reached at steve_kelman@harvard.edu.

The Fed 100

Read the profiles of all this year's winners.

Featured

  • Shutterstock image (by wk1003mike): cloud system fracture.

    Does the IRS have a cloud strategy?

    Congress and watchdog agencies have dinged the IRS for lacking an enterprise cloud strategy seven years after it became the official policy of the U.S. government.

  • Shutterstock image: illuminated connections between devices.

    Who won what in EIS

    The General Services Administration posted detailed data on how the $50 billion Enterprise Infrastructure Solutions contract might be divvied up.

  • Wikimedia Image: U.S. Cyber Command logo.

    Trump elevates CyberCom to combatant command status

    The White House announced a long-planned move to elevate Cyber Command to the status of a full combatant command.

  • Photo credit: John Roman Images / Shutterstock.com

    Verizon plans FirstNet rival

    Verizon says it will carve a dedicated network out of its extensive national 4G LTE network for first responders, in competition with FirstNet.

  • AI concept art

    Can AI tools replace feds?

    The Heritage Foundation is recommending that hundreds of thousands of federal jobs be replaced by automation as part of a larger government reorganization strategy.

  • DOD Common Access Cards

    DOD pushes toward CAC replacement

    Defense officials hope the Common Access Card's days are numbered as they continue to test new identity management solutions.

Reader comments

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above

More from 1105 Public Sector Media Group