Lawmakers focus on fairness to small businesses

SBA reauthorization bill proposes measures designed to level the competitive playing field

The Senate bill to reauthorize the Small Business Administration includes measures intended to make smaller firms more competitive and prevent small-business dollars from flowing to the coffers of larger firms.

The legislation would let SBA create tiers within small-business categories, subdividing them into smaller and larger small businesses. The Commerce Department used a similar strategy with its Commerce Information Technology Solutions-Next Generation contract.

COMMITS NexGen, which is set aside exclusively for small businesses, allows companies in the smallest tier to compete against larger companies if they choose to, but larger firms cannot compete in tiers reserved for smaller companies.

The Senate legislation also requires companies to recertify their size and small-business status every year. Such annual certification has been a topic of debate among government officials and businesses for years. Some argue that requiring annual certification is a drain on a company’s resources and that agencies should only require the recertification when awarding or extending a contract. Others, however, say that less frequent certifications allow companies to get funds intended for small firms even after they no longer qualify.

“Annual recertification goes over like a ton of bricks,” said Larry Allen, executive vice president of the Coalition for Government Procurement. “Most people in industry and government perceive that to be an overreaction.” Contracting officers already have the power to require businesses to certify their size status when awarding or extending contracts.

“There are fluctuations in the marketplace from year to year, so that a business may not be a small business in one year and be one again the next,” Allen said. “If they lose that small-business designation, they may lose set-aside business, and that puts them right back into the small category.”

Annual recertification can pose a problem for larger businesses, too, said Shiv Krishnan, president and chief executive officer at Indus.

“If you have smaller businesses that are part of your [subcontractor] team and you are in the middle of a major implementation, if one of your subcontractors is no longer treated as a small business and the government says you can’t use the company, it puts everyone in a bind,” he said.

Several recent studies prove that large companies occasionally take small-business contracts, and they have identified several causes. In some cases, a company outgrows the status but does not have to relinquish its small-business contracts until they expire or come up for optional extensions.

In other cases, larger companies acquire small firms, or contracting officers enter information incorrectly, resulting in errors. The studies’ sponsors have been reluctant to level accusations of deliberate fraud, but many small-business advocates say that also contributes to the problem.

When agencies incorrectly designate funds for small businesses, the error throws off the government’s efforts to measure whether it is meeting goals for awarding contracts to small businesses.

Agencies are trying to curb the problem. In December 2004, for example, SBA created a policy that a business getting small-business contracts transferred from other companies — which often happens in acquisitions or mergers — must recertify its small-business status. The process, called novation, means that if a new organization created through a merger isn’t a small business, the contract no longer counts toward the government’s small-business performance goals, according to SBA.

Some SBA critics say the Senate legislation is a way for larger companies to muscle in on small-business contracts. Lloyd Chapman, president of the American Small Business League, said allowing tiers within small-business categories “gives the [SBA] administrator the ability to create tiers any way he wants to.”

Major provisions of the SBA reauthorization billThe Senate’s proposed Small Business Administration legislation includes measures that would:
  • Require federal agencies to establish procedures for setting aside multiple-award contracts — in whole or in part — for small businesses.

  • Require the Office of Management and Budget to issue guidelines on analyzing purchase card use to identify opportunities for small-business participation in the program.

  • Establish the procedure for filing protests when the grounds for protest is an allegation regarding a company’s size status.

  • Increase funding for SBA’s Office of Veterans Business Development, to $2 million for fiscal 2007, $2.1 million for fiscal 2008 and $2.2 million for fiscal 2009.


  • Workforce
    online collaboration (elenabsl/

    Federal employee job satisfaction climbed during pandemic

    The survey documents the rapid change to teleworking postures in government under the COVID-19 pandemic.

  • Workforce
    By Mark Van Scyoc Royalty-free stock photo ID: 285175268

    OPM nominee plans focus on telework, IT, retirement

    Kiran Ahuja, a veteran of the Office of Personnel Management, told lawmakers that she thinks that the lack of consistent leadership in the top position at OPM has taken a toll on the ability of the agency to complete longer term IT modernization projects.

Stay Connected