Democrats gain the advantage on health IT issues

With Democrats now in charge on Capitol Hill, the rush for national health IT legislation is on

Tax Relief and Health Care Act of 2006

Related Links

In the past year, lawmakers have struggled in their efforts to pass health information technology legislation. The Senate and House each passed a bill that they sent to a conference committee by early fall, but the prospects for creating a framework for a National Health Information Network died without ever being presented for a full vote in either chamber.

“We all worked so hard, so we were extremely disappointed that Congress threw away all the progress that had been made over the past two years — when there was real opportunity to pass a good bill,” said David Merritt, a project director at the Center for Health Transformation, a health policy think tank that former House Speaker Newt Gingrich founded. “It’s not like this was Social Security or Medicare reform. This was a bipartisan issue.”

Now it’s the Democrats’ turn, and the new majority party appears to be committed to tackling health care issues. Health IT advocates are optimistic the new leadership will make health IT a priority, build on the progress of the past two years and create a better, more comprehensive legislative framework.

Ticia Gerber, vice president of public policy and international programs at the eHealth Initiative, said the Democrats’ focus on health care could result in a completely different approach to health IT. She said IT is likely to be included as a subset of many larger health care issues Democrats want to tackle, including stem cell research, Medicare and children’s health insurance.

“I can see where a lot of these bigger goals have the potential to have health IT and quality measures,” she said. “A bill for improving access for the uninsured, for example, might include ways that health IT can be used to better serve the underserved more efficiently and effectively.”

Meanwhile, IT is likely to remain a strongly bipartisan issue — some even refer to it as nonpartisan. “We’re talking about shades of a color, not different colors,” said Scott Wallace, president and chief executive officer of the National Alliance for Health IT.

But no one believes that the Democrats will address health IT in the same way that the Republicans did. Observers say several prominent themes are likely to dominate this year’s debate.

Privacy advocates nearly were in despair last summer after the House passed its bill without including any privacy protections and the Senate bill relied only on existing Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act language. Now that the Democrats are in charge, “We’re ecstatic,” said Dr. Deborah Peel, executive director of the Patient Privacy Rights Foundation.

House Democrats in particular have a recent history of fervent concern for privacy, Merritt said, having countered the House bill last summer with an amendment that included a menu of privacy safeguards, including the right to consent to data disclosure, the right to opt into and out of electronic databases, a right to audit trails and a private right of action if and when privacy breaches occur.

Michael Zamore, a senior policy adviser to Rep. Patrick Kennedy (D-R.I.) said the inclusion of strong privacy provisions will be critical to the passage of any health IT bill because many Democratic lawmakers believe that without strong privacy protections, health IT will fail in the long term.

“Success in transforming health care through information technology is predicated on a level of acceptance and trust by consumers,” Zamore said. “If that trust level isn’t there, then the whole IT enterprise will be set back. There’s nothing that could undo the years of effort toward a digital health information system faster than one or more highly publicized breaches that compromise patient privacy.”

Personal health records
Some Democrats see personal health records as a tipping point for health IT, said Dave Roberts, vice president of government relations for the Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society.

“If they can get consumers bought into electronic health care, they believe that there will be more of a transformation, so I think there will be a lot of focus on personal health records and how they might be legislated,” Roberts said.

Last fall, for example, Kennedy introduced the Personal Health Information Act, which aimed to support the rapid use and adoption of personal records, and he will likely introduce a similar measure this year or try to get the main provisions incorporated into a larger health IT bill.

Hayes is a freelance writer based in Stuarts Draft, Va.
Paying for health IT initiatives will be a big challengeDemocrats are expected to put a lot more money into health information technology than Republicans were willing to do last year, said Ticia Gerber, vice president of public policy and international programs at the eHealth Initiative. Gerber expects not only competitive grants but also a broad range of funding vehicles to be proposed.

But Scott Wallace, president and chief executive officer of the National Alliance for Health IT, said he doesn’t think Democrats will deliver one giant blank health IT check. “I think Democrats will look to provide funding in specific targeted niches where the IT adoption gap is growing and the implementations of that adoption gap is detrimental to the broader scale of medicine,” he said. “The debate will likely address: How do we use our resources to drive this into smaller practices and underserved communities?”

Dave Roberts, vice president of government relations for the Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society, said House Democrats may have hampered themselves by committing to pay-as-you-go budgeting rules. This requires legislators to pull funding from existing programs or raise taxes to pay for any new proposed initiatives.

“That’s going to be a real trick,” he said, adding that health IT will need to compete for dollars with a number of existing and critical health care issues, including finding a fix for scheduled Medicare physician reimbursement cuts.

— Heather B. Hayes


  • Workforce
    White House rainbow light shutterstock ID : 1130423963 By zhephotography

    White House rolls out DEIA strategy

    On Tuesday, the Biden administration issued agencies a roadmap to guide their efforts to develop strategic plans for diversity, equity, inclusion and accessibility (DEIA), as required under a as required under a June executive order.

  • Defense
    software (whiteMocca/

    Why DOD is so bad at buying software

    The Defense Department wants to acquire emerging technology faster and more efficiently. But will its latest attempts to streamline its processes be enough?

Stay Connected