Panel: Government data-mining programs need more scrutiny

The federal government should systematically evaluate the effectiveness and lawfulness of homeland security-related data mining and behavioral surveillance programs before deployment, according to a new report from a committee of the National Research Council of the National Academies.

“Protecting Individual Privacy in the Struggle Against Terrorists,” a 300-plus page report released today by a committee of privacy, national security and intelligence experts, lays out an extensive framework for how the government should assess and oversee data and information-based programs being used to fight terrorism.

The Committee on Technical and Privacy Dimensions of Information for Terrorism Prevention and Other National Goals also recommends that Congress reexamine existing laws to consider how privacy should be protected in current information-based counterterrorism programs.

"The framework is not designed simply, if you will, balance privacy and security, but rather with the intention of accomplishing both privacy and security," said Fred Cate, a commissioner and director of the Indiana University’s Center for Applied Cybersecurity Research.

The committee, which was supported by the Homeland Security Department and the National Science Foundation, was first convened in late 2005. The group sought to provide guidance to policy-makers, government officials and industry as they explore new surveillance tools for use in national security.

The years since the 2001 terrorist attacks have seen a proliferation of data mining and surveillance programs by government agencies. Some privacy advocates have questioned whether current laws adequately address the issues posed by these programs.

The committee’s findings stem from analysis of unclassified government programs and interviews with officials. However, members of the committee said that its conclusions apply to classified programs as well.

The report recommends evaluating proposed programs by the following criteria:

  • The program’s objective is clearly stated.

  • The program fully complies with applicable law.

  • The program’s false positive rate is acceptably low.

  • The program is audited at least annually.

  • Uses of personally identifiable information have received proper approval.

The report also emphasized the importance of data quality when it comes to protecting the privacy of people who are not terrorists.

"Individuals claimed by law enforcement officials to match prints found at a crime scene have sometimes turned out not to match upon further investigation," the report states. "Also, matching names or other forms of record linkage are error-prone operations, generally because of data quality issues."

According to the report, committee members believe current policies do not adequately address concerns with the shortcomings in current analytic techniques. The committee also concluded that automated terrorist identification through data mining was not feasible.

About the Author

Ben Bain is a reporter for Federal Computer Week.

FCW in Print

In the latest issue: Looking back on three decades of big stories in federal IT.


  • Anne Rung -- Commerce Department Photo

    Exit interview with Anne Rung

    The government's departing top acquisition official said she leaves behind a solid foundation on which to build more effective and efficient federal IT.

  • Charles Phalen

    Administration appoints first head of NBIB

    The National Background Investigations Bureau announced the appointment of its first director as the agency prepares to take over processing government background checks.

  • Sen. James Lankford (R-Okla.)

    Senator: Rigid hiring process pushes millennials from federal work

    Sen. James Lankford (R-Okla.) said agencies are missing out on younger workers because of the government's rigidity, particularly its protracted hiring process.

  • FCW @ 30 GPS

    FCW @ 30

    Since 1987, FCW has covered it all -- the major contracts, the disruptive technologies, the picayune scandals and the many, many people who make federal IT function. Here's a look back at six of the most significant stories.

  • Shutterstock image.

    A 'minibus' appropriations package could be in the cards

    A short-term funding bill is expected by Sept. 30 to keep the federal government operating through early December, but after that the options get more complicated.

  • Defense Secretary Ash Carter speaks at the TechCrunch Disrupt conference in San Francisco

    DOD launches new tech hub in Austin

    The DOD is opening a new Defense Innovation Unit Experimental office in Austin, Texas, while Congress debates legislation that could defund DIUx.

Reader comments

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above

More from 1105 Public Sector Media Group