Can we fight cyber crime like the Untouchables fought Capone?

The feds eventually brought down Al Capone not with Tommy guns but with federal tax laws

Recent successful legal action against the Waledac botnet offers some hope that lawyers might succeed where technology has failed in the war against cyber crime.

There appears to be little relief in sight from the relentless onslaught of spam that continues to deliver malicious code and phishing lures to our inboxes every day. According to Symantec’s latest monthly “State of Spam and Phishing Report,” spam made up more than 92 percent of e-mail last month. The percentage of spam has fluctuated from a low of about 79 percent in November 2009 to more than 95 percent, but it has held fairly steady at about 90 percent for most of the past year.

However, there might be a small patch of light on the horizon, coming from — of all places — the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, where a judge has recommended that ownership of 276 Internet domains used by the Waledac botnet be turned over to Microsoft. If that judgment comes down from the court, it would effectively cut off the botnet’s command and control network.

That action, part of Microsoft’s Operation b49 to use existing federal laws against organized cyber crime, cannot totally stop the criminals. Communications in the Waledac botnet have been effectively shut down since March, soon after Microsoft first went to court. But volumes of spam — one of the most effective means of delivering malware and opening doors for criminals — bounce back every time a botnet is taken down. However, the legal technique of attacking the criminals eventually could prove more effective than improving spam filters and antivirus engines.

Operation b49 was an attempt by Microsoft and other members of the Botnet Task Force to document the scope and source of spam being distributed by hundreds of thousands of Waledac-infected computers. The company estimated the botnet’s capacity at more than 1.5 billion messages a day and documented about 651 different spam messages sent to Hotmail e-mail accounts alone during three weeks in December.

Microsoft filed suit Feb. 22 alleging violations of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, the CAN-SPAM Act, the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, and other federal fraud and trademark protection laws. The company alleged that the unnamed defendants controlled the domains used for overseeing command and control of the botnet and luring unsuspecting victims to malicious sites.

A court granted a preliminary injunction in February that effectively cut the domains off from the .com top-level domain, and on Sept. 8, a magistrate judge recommended that the court grant a default judgment to permanently give Microsoft ownership of the domains. The defendants, John Does 1 through 27, have two weeks to object to the decision before the judgment becomes final, and because they have not yet appeared in court or responded to the suit, an objection is unlikely.

Although Microsoft appears on its way to winning this battle, we are still a long way from winning the war. Cyber crime will not stop until it becomes unprofitable. Right now, it apparently is very profitable. The cost of finding and exploiting vulnerabilities, finding ways around defenses, and conducting social engineering attacks is minuscule compared with the potential rewards from successfully compromising computers. Securing our PCs is unlikely to change that equation.

That doesn't mean we should give up on IT security. Properly secured desktops, servers and networks are important lines of defense, but they should be the last lines, not the first. Success will come when we increase the stakes and odds against the criminals. It is worthwhile to remember that the federal team named the Untouchables brought down Al Capone not with Tommy Guns but with federal tax laws.

Staff writer William Jackson writes the Cybereye blog on

About the Author

William Jackson is a Maryland-based freelance writer.


  • Defense
    DOD photo by Senior Airman Perry Aston  11th Wing Public Affairs

    How DOD's executive exodus could affect tech modernization

    Back-to-back resignations raise concerns about how things will be run without permanent leadership in key areas from policy to tech development.

  • Budget
    cybersecurity (vs148/

    House's DHS funding bill would create public-private cyber center

    The legislation would give $2.25 billion to DHS' cyber wing and set up an integrated cybersecurity center with other agencies, state and local governments and private industry.

Stay Connected


Sign up for our newsletter.

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.