Health care reform creates 'target-rich environment'

health insurance form

The computer system that allows the federal government to confirm the eligibility of health insurance applicants under the 2010 health care law is coming under fire for delays in security checks as the Oct. 1 deadline for open enrollment approaches and the plan's health insurance exchanges – called marketplaces – open for business.

"We are on schedule and will be ready for the marketplaces to open on October 1," CMS spokesman Brian Cook said. "CMS has extensive experience building and operating information technology systems that handle sensitive data. This experience comes from many years administering the Medicare, Medicaid, and CHIP programs."

Critics are less confident. At issue is the security of the data hub that will connect the health insurance exchanges with information from disparate federal sources, including the Internal Revenue Service, the Department of Homeland Security, Veterans Affairs, the Social Security Administration and others. The system is being built under the supervision of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), a component of the Department of Health and Human Services. According to a recent memorandum report from the Inspector General at CMS, the deadline for authorizing the security of the data hub has been pushed back to Sept. 30, just one day before the exchanges are set to open for business nationwide.

Steven Parente, a professor at the University of Minnesota who specializes in health economics and IT worries that the scope of the data hub is bigger than anything the agency has previously attempted. He called attention to the data hubs as a potential "privacy nightmare" in an influential op-ed published in USA Today in 2012. "No one has really done eligibility at this scale. Up to 300 million people can potentially purchase insurance on the exchanges," he told FCW.

Because of the size, the hub is a "target-rich environment" for fraud, Parente said. It's designed to facilitate the flow of information between agency databases, but it's expressly not designed to store data. However, there is an exception for data that doesn't match up with government information. These are stored for review and possible correction. Parente said this "creates a huge spoofing opportunity" for hackers.

Parente attributes some of the delays in testing and authorizing the system to politics. He notes that the Obama administration wasn't sure until 2012 that the law would be upheld by the Supreme Court. The system required the cooperation of multiple agencies that are accustomed to operating under different data privacy regimes.

A statement of work put out by CMS in July 2011 gives a hint at the jurisdictional muddle surrounding data security in the new systems. Health data is covered by statute under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) and the Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act of 2009 (HITECH). The sharing of databases among agencies is governed by the Privacy Act of 1974. Under the e-Government Act of 2002, agencies must perform privacy impact assessments when collecting and using personally identifiable information. The entire system must be compliant with the Federal Information Security Management Act.

Despite delays and hurdles, Parente is expecting the data hubs to go online on schedule and interact effectively with the federal exchange at He's less certain whether the Hub will connect with the individual exchanges established by states. But he points out that the government has more of a cushion than the Oct. 1 deadline would indicate. Coverage doesn't begin until Jan. 1, 2014, and open enrollment extends through March 31. So if the hub launches with a few glitches, there will be time to address them.

Still, the delays are themselves proving a target-rich environment for committed opponents of the overhaul. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) released a letter to CMS Administrator Marilyn Tavenner requesting public assurances that the center's CIO "will not be pressured to certify the system's readiness by signing the Security Decision Authorization" until it is secure. Rep. Patrick Meehan (R-Pa.), who has held hearings on the readiness of the program's technology, reiterated his concerns about the viability of the Oct. 1 launch date in a statement. "According to CMS' own report, there is no indication that they will be able to secure Americans' sensitive information, leaving millions of families targets of fraud and identity theft. In the rush to meet arbitrary deadlines, I'm concerned that corners will be cut and mistakes will be made. The alarms are sounding," Meehan said.

Yevgeniy Feyman, a research associate at the conservative-leaning Manhattan Institute said part of the problem is that the health care law raised expectations for purchasers. "The mistake was trying to frame this as being as easy as purchasing an airline ticket or booking a hotel online," he said. "Realistically, applying for health insurance is a long process."

The security of the data hub is of such a great concern because of the sensitivity of the information that passes over the system. Applicants using the exchanges will be asked to share Social Security numbers, IRS tax IDs, employment status, income, military service, and other information in addition to their basic personal information. The goal is an end-to-end confirmation system that pulls in records from relevant agencies to determine whether applicants are eligible for coverage under the law.

According to CMS, the hub provides a one-source connection for all the health services under the CMS umbrella, including Medicare, Medicaid, the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP), and the insurance exchanges. The single hub eliminates vulnerabilities that might exist with multiple data connections coming from individual state exchange.

Testing is ongoing through the end of August, involving state exchanges, insurance providers, and the federal agencies whose data is set to stream over the hub once it opens.

About the Author

Adam Mazmanian is executive editor of FCW.

Before joining the editing team, Mazmanian was an FCW staff writer covering Congress, government-wide technology policy, health IT and the Department of Veterans Affairs. Prior to joining FCW, Mr. Mazmanian was technology correspondent for National Journal and served in a variety of editorial roles at B2B news service SmartBrief. Mazmanian started his career as an arts reporter and critic, and has contributed reviews and articles to the Washington Post, the Washington City Paper, Newsday, Architect magazine, and other publications. He was an editorial assistant and staff writer at the now-defunct New York Press and arts editor at the online network in the 1990s, and was a weekly contributor of music and film reviews to the Washington Times from 2007 to 2014.

Click here for previous articles by Mazmanian. Connect with him on Twitter at @thisismaz.

The Fed 100

Read the profiles of all this year's winners.


  • Then-presidential candidate Donald Trump at a 2016 campaign event. Image: Shutterstock

    'Buy American' order puts procurement in the spotlight

    Some IT contractors are worried that the "buy American" executive order from President Trump could squeeze key innovators out of the market.

  • OMB chief Mick Mulvaney, shown here in as a member of Congress in 2013. (Photo credit Gage Skidmore/Flickr)

    White House taps old policies for new government makeover

    New guidance from OMB advises agencies to use shared services, GWACs and federal schedules for acquisition, and to leverage IT wherever possible in restructuring plans.

  • Shutterstock image (by Everett Historical): aerial of the Pentagon.

    What DOD's next CIO will have to deal with

    It could be months before the Defense Department has a new CIO, and he or she will face a host of organizational and operational challenges from Day One

  • USAF Gen. John Hyten

    General: Cyber Command needs new platform before NSA split

    U.S. Cyber Command should be elevated to a full combatant command as soon as possible, the head of Strategic Command told Congress, but it cannot be separated from the NSA until it has its own cyber platform.

  • Image from Shutterstock.

    DLA goes virtual

    The Defense Logistics Agency is in the midst of an ambitious campaign to eliminate its IT infrastructure and transition to using exclusively shared, hosted and virtual services.

  • Fed 100 logo

    The 2017 Federal 100

    The women and men who make up this year's Fed 100 are proof positive of what one person can make possibile in federal IT. Read on to learn more about each and every winner's accomplishments.

Reader comments

Tue, Aug 13, 2013

Lets not miss the big reason why critics of the program see a big potential for fraud associated with this system. The healthcare reform act was put together and passed through fraud that included: hidden taxes, false promises, outright lies, other forms of deception, and even breaking the rules just to get the thing created and passed. Since many recognize that the entire package is a fraud, it is no surprise that we expect the system created to be abused and filled with fraud. It certainly was not created to make our society more open and honest.

Tue, Aug 13, 2013

And I'm sure with Congress' oversight nothing will go live until it meets with their approval. That way if something goes wrong, and there is a data loss, they can share the blame instead of just point fingers (like they usually do). I have an idea, disabel telnet, that will secure everything... On top of that, give everybody a CAC card and there's no way anything could go wrong. Oh, darn, it's the server that's the issue. Dang! Well, put that puppy in a expired DoD data center or some overpriced private data center and all will be fine! What could go wrong?! No?? Well BOHICA then!

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above

More from 1105 Public Sector Media Group