Cloud Computing

6 questions for IBM, Amazon and the CIA

concept art for cloud services

Oral arguments in Amazon Web Services' complaint against the U.S. government over its decision to request the CIA to rebid a $600 million cloud computing contract it won in early 2013 began Oct .7 in a closed U.S. Court of Federal Claims courtroom.

The arguments presented by attorneys for AWS, the Department of Justice – representing the CIA – and IBM, which filed a successful bid protest the Government Accountability Office upheld in June, will be made behind closed doors despite Judge Thomas Wheeler's expressed preference for an open proceeding.

Court documents show that IBM and AWS motioned for oral arguments to be held out of public view because of expected references to "proprietary, competitively sensitive information," which Wheeler granted Oct. 4.

While the content of their arguments won't be made public, the narrative is. On Oct. 1, Wheeler ordered parties to address six specific questions during oral argument.

1. Was IBM's protest of the CIA's pricing requirement filed in a timely manner?

2. Based on the agency's evaluation of proposals, did IBM have a substantial chance of receiving the contract award?

3. In the absence of the GAO's June 6 decision recommending corrective action, would the CIA have issued RFP Amendment 5 containing 47 changes and clarifications?

4. Of the 47 changes and clarifications contained in RFP Amendment 5, which of them, if any, did the agency regard as material changes to the RFP requirements?

5. In soliciting a new round of proposals from Amazon and IBM, why did the CIA not open the competition to all interested parties?

6. What is the current status of the agency's procurement, in terms of the planned contract award date and the urgency of the agency's needs?

The questions delve deeply into GAO's sustainment of IBM's bid protest and the CIA's handling of the cloud computing procurement.

While the intelligence community recently rolled out its own internal cloud computing infrastructure based on the National Security Agency's internal model, since at least early 2012 the IC has been seeking an industry partner to build for all intelligence agencies a cloud unlike any ever developed.

In 2012, Microsoft and AT&T competed for the CIA's initial procurement of the contract but eventually dropped out, as did one other unidentified vendor. It has been a two-horse race since, despite the CIA following GAO's recommendations to rebid the contract in August, and Wheeler wants an explanation for why the competition wasn't opened to other parties.

While AWS, IBM and the CIA are not commenting on specifics regarding the case as this point, one likely explanation is that the CIA's time-frame for procuring a commercially developed internal cloud has been delayed significantly.

Government attorneys advised the judge on Oct. 4 they would respond to the status of the agency's procurement, but were hesitant to disclose the procurement's urgency in a public setting because of national security concerns. Such top-secret information could only be discussed in a closed hearing, they said.

The CIA is waiting for the court's ruling before it makes another award, despite having the rebid proposals since August. A ruling is not expected until mid-October.

About the Author

Frank Konkel is a former staff writer for FCW.

The Fed 100

Read the profiles of all this year's winners.


  • Shutterstock image (by wk1003mike): cloud system fracture.

    Does the IRS have a cloud strategy?

    Congress and watchdog agencies have dinged the IRS for lacking an enterprise cloud strategy seven years after it became the official policy of the U.S. government.

  • Shutterstock image: illuminated connections between devices.

    Who won what in EIS

    The General Services Administration posted detailed data on how the $50 billion Enterprise Infrastructure Solutions contract might be divvied up.

  • Wikimedia Image: U.S. Cyber Command logo.

    Trump elevates CyberCom to combatant command status

    The White House announced a long-planned move to elevate Cyber Command to the status of a full combatant command.

  • Photo credit: John Roman Images /

    Verizon plans FirstNet rival

    Verizon says it will carve a dedicated network out of its extensive national 4G LTE network for first responders, in competition with FirstNet.

  • AI concept art

    Can AI tools replace feds?

    The Heritage Foundation is recommending that hundreds of thousands of federal jobs be replaced by automation as part of a larger government reorganization strategy.

  • DOD Common Access Cards

    DOD pushes toward CAC replacement

    Defense officials hope the Common Access Card's days are numbered as they continue to test new identity management solutions.

Reader comments

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above

More from 1105 Public Sector Media Group