Management

Don't throw me into the savings tar pit

Shutterstock image.

At a recent hearing of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, Federal CIO Steven VanRoekel said improvements in IT portfolio management and cost oversight have yielded more than $2.5 billion in identified cost savings and $1.9 billion in realized savings. Specifically, the PortfolioStat process and consolidation of commodity IT drove the efficiencies.

Barely was VanRoekel finished with this opening gambit when the stakes were raised. "The target should be much higher than that," argued David Powner, director of IT management issues at the Government Accountability Office. He went on to argue that "based on our work, there are over 200 PortfolioStat initiatives that agencies are working on to eliminate at least $5.5 billion in duplicative savings."

So GAO had the high bid, for two weeks. Then doubling down -- and doubling down again -- came a study by MeriTalk based on a survey of 300 federal network managers. According to the study's sponsor, the U.S. government has the potential to achieve $11.2 billion in annual savings by taking full advantage of data center consolidation, virtualization, cloud computing, remote access and infrastructure diversification. If network managers were able to significantly increase network speed, the survey further claims, agencies could save an additional $11 billion in one year.

So if agencies were to fully implement those five initiatives, they could save more than one-quarter of the government's annual $80 billion IT budget.

Coincidentally or not, it's the $20 billion-plus figure I've heard most often in conversations with House and Senate members and staff. But over the years, I've come to worry whenever cost savings are claimed. And here is why.

Economy and efficiency are major tenets of traditional public administration doctrine. One hears over and over about a government that works better and costs less or about the need to do more with less. But as Rufus Miles, an author and federal administrator who served as an assistant secretary under three presidents, asserted, "Economy as a ground for major reorganization is a will-o'-the-wisp."

"It is impossible to prove after the fact, how much, if any, has been saved," he went on to say. "Since it is never possible to know what costs would have been without the reorganization, such calculations are close to meaningless."

For validation, one need only look at the annual reports issued by inspectors general across the government. Look at the savings claimed, the "funds put to better use," the economies and efficiencies, and the allegations of fraud, abuse and waste. If only half of them were real, the federal government would be showing a budget surplus this year instead of a massive deficit.

And beware the law of unintended consequences. Several come to mind from the Clinton-era Reinventing Government initiative. A report from the National Performance Review at the time estimated that $108 billion would be saved in the final five years of the Clinton-Gore term, while agencies' reinvention activities would realize more than $10 billion in savings and recommendations from NPR's second phase would yield $69.6 billion in savings for a grand total of $188 billion in five years.

Re-engineering the bureaucracy would also streamline government and reduce the civilian government workforce by 272,900 full-time equivalents.

The result? The newly elected Congress, led by then-House Speaker Newt Gingrich, methodically went about "capturing" those claimed dollar and personnel savings -- and devastated acquisition and other administrative areas for years to come.

About the Author

Alan P. Balutis is senior director and distinguished fellow at Cisco Systems.

The Fed 100

Save the date for 28th annual Federal 100 Awards Gala.

Featured

  • computer network

    How Einstein changes the way government does business

    The Department of Commerce is revising its confidentiality agreement for statistical data survey respondents to reflect the fact that the Department of Homeland Security could see some of that data if it is captured by the Einstein system.

  • Defense Secretary Jim Mattis. Army photo by Monica King. Jan. 26, 2017.

    Mattis mulls consolidation in IT, cyber

    In a Feb. 17 memo, Defense Secretary Jim Mattis told senior leadership to establish teams to look for duplication across the armed services in business operations, including in IT and cybersecurity.

  • Image from Shutterstock.com

    DHS vague on rules for election aid, say states

    State election officials had more questions than answers after a Department of Homeland Security presentation on the designation of election systems as critical U.S. infrastructure.

  • Org Chart Stock Art - Shutterstock

    How the hiring freeze targets millennials

    The government desperately needs younger talent to replace an aging workforce, and experts say that a freeze on hiring doesn't help.

  • Shutterstock image: healthcare digital interface.

    VA moves ahead with homegrown scheduling IT

    The Department of Veterans Affairs will test an internally developed scheduling module at primary care sites nationwide to see if it's ready to service the entire agency.

  • Shutterstock images (honglouwawa & 0beron): Bitcoin image overlay replaced with a dollar sign on a hardware circuit.

    MGT Act poised for a comeback

    After missing in the last Congress, drafters of a bill to encourage cloud adoption are looking for a new plan.

Reader comments

Thu, Jun 5, 2014 Cindy

Alan: Clever. Pith saves you the rigor of going through and actually calculating out which of the savings overlap or cancel each other out. You can just add them up and point to a big, bad number. Of course, if I worked for Cisco I'd be pretty opposed to savings of any kind too. Since you must defend the status quo at all costs, any money saved by better government comes right out of your revenue line.

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above

More from 1105 Public Sector Media Group