FBI lawyer says encryption has a purpose

FBI General Counsel James Baker said the bureau doesn't hate encryption. It just has to turn over every possible stone when fighting terrorism.

Addressing the International Association of Privacy Professionals' Global Privacy Summit on April 5, Baker downplayed the animosity between the FBI and Apple during the much-publicized court battle over unlocking an iPhone used by one of the San Bernardino, Calif., shooters.

Media reports have "not [been] exactly representative" of the conversations between the FBI and the technology industry, which Baker said have been less combative and more mutually respectful.

In the case of the San Bernardino shooter's phone, the legal dispute was truncated when a mystery third party offered the FBI a way to get into the phone.

"We have not shared the solution with Apple to date," Baker said. FBI officials had access to the shooter's iCloud backups before they accessed the contents of the phone, but he declined to say whether they had recovered any new data. And he defended the fight with Apple as a necessary exercise in exploring legal options.

Baker also argued that law enforcement needs access to the contents of electronic communication, rather than just the metadata associated with it, to protect Americans from terrorism. "Content is hugely important," he said.

But ultimately, he said, the American people will need to decide the future of encryption. Do we want strong end-to-end encryption (the only kind that technologists say works), or do we want to give law enforcement keys to information?

Baker admitted that encryption has its appeal, especially in light of the massive hack of federal employee data in the Office of Personnel Management breach. "I wish that data had been encrypted," he said, adding that he and his family were among the breach's victims.

One audience member asked why the FBI doesn't focus on getting more resources, hiring technologists and trying to find vulnerabilities in relevant technology instead of pressuring companies to establish backdoors to their products.

"That is a reasonable approach," Baker said. "I don't know if that's the right approach."

He added, "We haven't taken that approach."

About the Author

Zach Noble is a former FCW staff writer.


  • Oversight
    President of the United States of America, Donald J. Trump, attends the 2019 Army Navy Game in Philadelphia, Pa., Dec. 14, 2019. (U.S. Army photo by Sgt. Dana Clarke)

    Trump shakes up official watchdog ranks

    The White House removed an official designated to provide oversight to the $2 trillion rescue and relief fund and nominated a raft of new appointees to handle oversight chores at multiple agencies.

  • Workforce
    coronavirus molecule (creativeneko/

    OMB urges 'maximum telework flexibilities' for DC-area feds

    A Sunday evening memo ahead of a potentially chaotic commute urges agency heads to pivot to telework as much as possible.

Stay Connected


Sign up for our newsletter.

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.