What students think of government cyber jobs
- By Chase Gunter
- Mar 22, 2019
Getting cybersecurity and tech talent into government has been a top management priority spanning administrations, but there remain fundamental challenges in selling government as an employer.
The U.S. Cyber Challenge, launched by former Federal CIO Karen Evans in 2010, holds camps and competitions around the country and helps students burnish their resumes and introduces them to recruiters.
USCCC leaders and participants said at a March 21 event that the government faces marketing and process challenges when it comes to attracting young cyber talent.
Doug Logan, USCC's chief technologist, said that for all the focus on government's inability to compete with private-sector pay, the exact dollar figure, while important, isn't disqualifying.
"The first reason why everyone tells me they don't want to work for the federal government is they think it's boring," he said. "The second reason why they say they don't want to work for the federal government is because they can't find job descriptions that match their entry-level capabilities because [agencies] all want people with a whole bunch of experience. The third reason is because the whole process of applying and actually getting hired in the federal government is horrible and painful and takes forever."
Andrew Meserote, whose team won the Nevada-based camp's capture the flag competition last summer, plans to join the Department of Defense civilian cybersecurity workforce, pending a security clearance. He said the "the recruitment process [for government] is definitely slower than private industry." The slow hiring process means "there's still the chance that even if you get your clearance, the job's not there anymore."
Nicholas Bruno, whose team won the USCC's competition in Delaware back in 2016, currently does cyber and programming for a private company, but he said that he'd be open to part-time position -- or a stint in government -- if moving back and forth between government and industry was more viable.
What he said was most appealing about the prospect of working in government included the training government jobs could provide, the work he wanted to do and the prospect of obtaining a security clearance as a badge for proving trustworthiness.
USCC National Director Glenn Hernandez said not enough emphasis is put on marketing federal cybersecurity employment to job candidates.
"OPM doesn't advertise these positions because they leave it to agencies to push their own things, and there's not that type of recognition that these types of folks that are coming into the workforce need to have a different culture in order to attract them," Hernandez said.
Once new hires are on board, it's important to challenge them with interesting work.
"If they're staring at a screen for eight to 10 hours a day, you just lost them. Within months," he said.
The administration is piloting ways of getting folks already in government to fill those vacant positions. Jason Gray, CIO of the Department of Education, said the early interest among current federal employees on learning cybersecurity skills via the Cyber Reskilling Academy is a good starting point.
Gray, who is also the chairman of the CIO Council's IT Workforce Committee, said the "real goal" of pilot was to see if the model of cybersecurity training was something that would generate interest.
The reskilling effort is " really focused on enhancing the employee, and in many cases, the employees will probably get the education and bring it back to their organization and further the cyber efforts," he said. "It's really a win-win, regardless of whether they transition out of the work that they're in right now."
Chase Gunter is a staff writer covering civilian agencies, workforce issues, health IT, open data and innovation.
Prior to joining FCW, Gunter reported for the C-Ville Weekly in Charlottesville, Va., and served as a college sports beat writer for the South Boston (Va.) News and Record. He started at FCW as an editorial fellow before joining the team full-time as a reporter.
Gunter is a graduate of the University of Virginia, where his emphases were English, history and media studies.
Click here for previous articles by Gunter, or connect with him on Twitter: @WChaseGunter