Gov Careers

By Phil Piemonte

Blog archive

Insourcing is not just a dollars issue

“We weren’t seeing the savings we had hoped from insourcing,” said Defense Secretary Robert Gates on Aug. 9.

He was referring to work DoD had brought back in-house from the private sector, and made the statement during a press conference to explain his sweeping new plan to cut overhead and make better use of the department’s dollars.

But does the lack of big-time savings from insourcing really mean that “insourcing doesn’t work”? Because that seems to be what some (media, contractors, etc.) have concluded from Gates’s statement.

Or does the focus on expected dollar savings from insourcing obscure—lest we forget—the “inherently governmental” motive that also underlies many insourcing initiatives?

Let’s take a step back.

Few would deny that contractors are an indispensable part of making things work. They allow the government to bypass huge capital investments to get access to the best solutions from the private sector. But when it comes down to basics, contractors—as private-sector entities—seek profits.

One fundamental premise of the whole “inherently governmental” rationale is that certain basic government functions should remain in-house because “insourcing” them eliminates the opportunity for profits ever to trump the public interest. It assures that the government’s discretion is being applied to the most critical decisions.

So it would seem that insourcing that satisfies this objective—even if it costs the same as an outsourced solution—would be judged a success.

Or are we missing something?

Posted by Phil Piemonte on Aug 13, 2010 at 12:13 PM


  • IT Modernization
    Eisenhower Executive Office Building (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

    OMB's user guide to the MGT Act

    The Office of Management and Budget is working on a rules-of-the-road document to cover how agencies can seek and use funds under the MGT Act.

  • global network (Pushish Images/

    As others see us -- a few surprises

    A recent dinner with civil servants from Asia delivered some interesting insights, Steve Kelman writes.

  • FCW Perspectives
    cloud (Singkham/

    A smarter approach to cloud

    Advances in cloud technology are shifting the focus toward choosing the right tool for the job and crafting solutions that truly modernize systems.

Stay Connected

FCW Update

Sign up for our newsletter.

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.