John Klossner

Blog archive

Klossner: Why young feds need manual pencil sharpeners

My children, in a back-to-school consumer mode that would warm the hearts of economic analysts and mall managers alike, are in love with battery-powered pencil sharpeners. Don't ask me how this came about.

A battery-powered pencil sharpener has appeared in our home, and my children are spending two to three hours a day with it. They look at it, take the batteries out and replace them again, and they sharpen pencils. (If any readers need a ream of pencils — or should I say a pod? a bunch? a rhumba? — sharpened, I'm contracting out.)

This has me worried about their development of small-muscle skills. Will an over-reliance on battery-powered pencil sharpeners prevent them from developing the hand coordination and forearm strength that years of manual pencil sharpening allowed my generation to enjoy? 

Will our country fall behind in the pencil-sharpening skills race? Because I am a middle-aged and sometimes "helicopter" parent (I've been known to occasionally sharpen a pencil for my child), this is but one of the many worries I have for my children's generation as I compare their childhood experiences with my own.

(As an aside, what are we calling this next generation? Since we started the generation monikers with Gen X, we've run out of alphabet pretty quickly. Do we just go to the beginning again? Any generation known as Generation A has an awful lot of pressure on it, not to mention the eternal resentment of Generation B. Do we start adding numbers? Does someone already have a Gen 2.0 billing? Do we start adding symbols? I'm sure it would look cool, but does anyone want to be part of Generation ampersand? Very poor foresight on the part of generation namers.)

My concern with pencil-sharpener skills also plays into one of the discussions surrounding the Rising Star Awards. The Rising Stars, as anyone reading this publication knows, are awarded to young federal employees who have shown unusual resilience and talent in dealing with the numerous challenges federal employment can throw at them. As I read bios for this year's recipients, images pop into my head of people swimming through shark-infested waters, rope gritted in their teeth, as they tow lunch to some fellow employees.

The discussion I'm referring to is about the challenges themselves. Whenever federal employees and employment are discussed, there is an immediate side conversation about what the government can and should be doing to attract and keep the best talent. There is always a comparison to the private sector, and the words "performance-based pay" and "bureaucracy" appear somewhere.

My thought is, similar to giving our children battery-powered pencil sharpeners, why do we want to make it easy? Is this helping these people become the best federal employees they can be? Shouldn't we be grateful that current government hiring and employment practices weed out those who expect better compensation and support? We aren't doing them any favors by creating a federal youth soccer league, where no score is kept and everyone gets a trophy. I for one am happy to know that the agency personnel I am dealing with are there because of their fanatical devotion to government work, not because it was the best-paying job available.

In fact, I propose we take it a couple of steps further: Don't advertise any job openings, relocate agency offices to undisclosed locations, and include a skills test consisting of candidates finding their way from Seattle, Wash., to Washington, D.C., using only public transportation, surviving for one week from a vending machine at the Environmental Protection Agency, and having to sit through two consecutive showings of Man of the Year without any refreshments for any who still insist on working for the federal government.

And don't give them any pencils.

Posted by John Klossner on Aug 26, 2008 at 12:18 PM


  • People
    Federal CIO Suzette Kent

    Federal CIO Kent to exit in July

    During her tenure, Suzette Kent pushed on policies including Trusted Internet Connection, identity management and the creation of the Chief Data Officers Council

  • Defense
    Essye Miller, Director at Defense Information Management, speaks during the Breaking the Gender Barrier panel at the Air Space, Cyber Conference in National Harbor, Md., Sept. 19, 2017. (U.S. Air Force photo/Staff Sgt. Chad Trujillo)

    Essye Miller: The exit interview

    Essye Miller, DOD's outgoing principal deputy CIO, talks about COVID, the state of the tech workforce and the hard conversations DOD has to have to prepare personnel for the future.

Stay Connected


Sign up for our newsletter.

I agree to this site's Privacy Policy.